Method
Editorial log
Every published page on this site, who reviewed it, when, and what the review changed.
Scaled content is penalised when it is published without review. Rather than assert that review happens, the record is kept here and the build will not publish a page whose review block is missing or dated before the page was written.
Some collections are checked automatically and the table says so rather than hiding it. Market pages carry no third-party figure — every publishable fact on one is a named authority, a section number, an institution or a link — so each is checked by retrieving the source and searching it, and the URL, the status, the hash and the matched passage are recorded. A field that cannot be established that way is dropped; a page whose required fields cannot be is not published. Practical guides are published under Siddharth Sharma's byline. The review log records the checks performed during production separately from author attribution; it does not treat an automated check as a person reading a piece.
| Page | Type | Reviewed by | Reviewed | What the review changed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| How should an AI agent handle uncertainty? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft recommended calibrated confidence reporting. Removed after considering how such a score would be used: attached to an assertion it invites arithmetic its calibration will not support. Replaced with named assumptions. Added the failure-versus-caveat distinction, which decides how the run is treated operationally and was missing. |
| How should an AI automation be designed? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added idempotency and processed-item state, which the draft omitted entirely and which produce failures that get attributed to the model. Also added the exception path as a design element rather than an afterthought, because an undefined one is how a successful-looking automation accumulates a hidden backlog. |
| How should an AI system react when evidence is missing? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the downstream requirement after noticing the draft stopped at reporting. A reported absence that the workflow continues past is the same silent gap one step later, which makes the reporting decorative. Also added absence counting, which is where the durable value of this discipline sits. |
| How should an AI workflow handle exceptions? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the acceptable-rate threshold, which the draft omitted and which is the only thing preventing the slow failure where an automation covers less and less while its description stays the same. Also promoted counting by type, which was a closing remark and is where the compounding value is. |
| How should coding-agent sessions be divided? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft divided sessions by duration and context usage, which are properties of the tool rather than of the work. Replaced with the reviewable change, which is a unit the process already defines. Added the investigative session as an explicit exception, since a strict change-per-session rule has nowhere to put understanding work. |
| How should evidence be separated from interpretation? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added assumptions as a third category, which the two-way split leaves nowhere to put and which is where most of the actionable content sits. Also added the readability caveat, since the draft's structure taken literally produces a document nobody reads, which defeats the checking it was designed for. |
| How should long-running agent tasks be structured? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft recommended periodic summarisation of the session. That is the mechanism this page identifies as lossy, so it was replaced with writing durable stage outputs and reading them back. Added the ordering point about checkable stages first, which changes how a plan is built rather than only how it is recorded. |
| How should context be compressed without losing important information? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft recommended better summarisation prompts. Replaced with naming survivors in advance, because the failure is not summary quality but that nobody chose what to lose. Added the requirement that a compressed context declare itself, which changes how the next reader treats it and was absent. |
| How should long-running agent work be checkpointed? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the case of a checkpoint that faithfully records a wrong path, which the draft's design does not survive: every recommendation assumed checkpoints are correct, and the recovery mechanism when they are not is retaining the earlier ones. That changes the storage requirement from a current-state file to an appended history. |
| How should parallel coding-agent work be isolated? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the closing case against parallelism. The draft assumed parallel work was the goal and described how to do it safely, which omits that two sequential runs are simpler and avoid every problem listed. Also added shared build artefacts, which cause the failures people misattribute to the agents themselves. |
| How should persistent work state be stored? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft weighed storage options on throughput and durability, which are the wrong axes for this workload. Rewritten around legibility during failure, which reverses the ranking. Kept the concurrency exception explicitly so the page does not read as an argument that files are always sufficient. |
| How should subagents return results? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the observed-versus-inferred split and the marking requirement, neither of which the draft had. Both address the same failure from different ends: a delegated result acquiring more authority than it earned, which is how a single weak conclusion propagates through everything the main run does afterwards. |
| How should you handle a mistake that came from AI? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the population check, which is what makes this different from ordinary error handling and which the draft omitted while focusing on the communication. A systematic error is a set rather than an instance, and correcting only what was noticed leaves the rest in place. |
| How should you run an AI agent for several hours? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft described how to sustain one long session. Replaced with consecutive short runs after establishing that the degradation is a property of accumulation rather than something to be managed, which changes the architecture rather than the technique. Added the unattended permission question, which the draft carried over from supervised operation without noticing the difference. |
| How should you structure a project for a coding agent? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft was a list of code hygiene practices, which are good advice and do not answer the question asked. Rebuilt around evaluation cost, which is what actually distinguishes a codebase where agent work pays from one where it does not. Added the legacy answer, since most readers are not starting from a clean repository. |
| Should a coding agent write the tests? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft answered no on independence grounds. That is wrong in a specific and fixable way — the problem is ordering rather than authorship — so the answer reversed. Added the implementation-asserting defect, which is the practical thing to review generated tests for and which coverage metrics actively reward. |
| Should AI have write access to your CRM? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the creation-versus-update distinction, which the draft did not address and which reverses the usual assumption in one specific way: creation is safer except for duplication, where the damage from a split customer history exceeds any single field error. |
| Should an agent ask clarifying questions before starting? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft answered yes and described how to prompt for good questions. Replaced with the restatement after establishing that questions only cover noticed ambiguity, which excludes the failure that matters. Kept the blocking question for genuinely missing inputs, since a restatement cannot resolve a fact that exists nowhere. |
| Should an AI agent explain its reasoning? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft recommended requiring explanations as a transparency measure. Split into two operations after considering what an explanation actually is as an artefact, which reverses the advice for the narrative half. Added the plan-before-work distinction so the page does not read as an argument against asking an agent to think out loud, which is a different and defensible practice. |
| Should research and implementation be handled by different agents? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft argued for specialised agents. Corrected to sessions after establishing that the same system does both jobs and the gain comes entirely from the context profile, which changes what a reader should build. Added the first-workable-approach point, which is a second and independent reason for the break. |
| Should verification be performed by a separate agent? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | The draft recommended a separate reviewer without specifying what it should see. That is the whole variable, so the page now turns on withholding the originating reasoning. Added the prohibition on the reviewer fixing its own findings, which is the obvious efficiency and destroys the independence that justified the arrangement. |
| Should you buy an AI tool or build the workflow yourself? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the hybrid as the primary recommendation rather than as a compromise, since it is what the two-sided test actually implies once the general and specific parts are separated. Also added the evaluation question about error handling, which does more to distinguish products than any capability comparison and appears in none of them. |
| Should you start a new AI session or continue the old one? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Cut a duration guideline. Session decay tracks material ingested rather than elapsed time, so any duration rule would be wrong in both directions and would be copied precisely because it is easy to apply. Added the phase-change reason, which is a restart trigger unrelated to degradation and was absent from the draft. |
| Should you tell clients you use AI? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the engagement terms answer, which resolves the recurring version of this question in advance and is cheaper than deciding case by case. Also separated the commercial reaction from the ethical question, because conflating them is how firms end up deciding a disclosure question on the basis of how a client might feel. |
| Should you use a model to grade a model? | Answer | Answer Production Engine | 2026-08-25 | Added the requirement to validate the grader against known-bad cases. Without it the page recommends adding an unmeasured measurement device, which is how teams end up confident in a number that has never caught anything. Cut a proposed scoring scale for the same reason the page argues against scores. |
What the build refuses to publish.
Four checks run before any page in this system is generated, and each one stops the build rather than producing a warning nobody reads.
A page must name, in writing, what is on it that could not appear unchanged on a sibling page — and no two pages may give the same answer. Independently of that, every page is reduced to a fingerprint with its own subject and place names masked out; if two fingerprints match, or come close, both pages are named and the build stops. That is the check that catches a page whose only distinguishing feature was the city in the heading.
A page must also carry at least two datapoints that are specific to its own subject rather than to its category, and if the same figure is claimed as specific on two different pages, it was specific to neither. Pages ship in cohorts with a size cap so indexation can be observed between them, and every page carries the review block that produces the table above.
All four are properties of the schema, not of anyone remembering. Reviewed by Siddharth Sharma, except the 0 market page(s) above, which are checked against their sources and carry the record of it.
GATES
A gate enforced by a person reading pages stops being enforced somewhere around page 60.